Second Main Phase Trading Co. - Magic: The Gathering singles, decks, collections bought
Dallas - Fort Worth

Sell Your Collection

transparent offers, priced from live data
The Hobbit key art: Bag EndThe Hobbit key art: My Precious
The HobbitBag EndMy Precious, art by Valera Lutfullina
We are buying. Tell us about your collection below and we reply within 24 hours, or email hello@secondmainphasetrading.com.

Tell us what you have

Who you're dealing with: two friends in North Texas. Trevor appraises and sorts every collection; Steven runs the pricing behind your offer. Your message reaches both of us. More about us.

We reply within 24 hours. Questions about payment, ID, meetups or shipping are answered in the seller FAQ. Curious first? Estimate what your collection is worth in under a minute.

How our offers work

Most collection offers are a single mystery number. Ours come in two visible parts, because your collection has two very different kinds of value in it:

The hits - your valuable singles, priced individually against live market data, with the list shown to you. You can check every number.

The bulk - the thousands of commons and uncommons that no store can sell individually, priced honestly at bulk rates rather than hidden inside a blended percentage.

That is the whole trick: there is no trick. You see what we counted, what we valued it at, and what we will pay. If a mail-in buylist would pay you more for a specific card, we will tell you so.

What we will buy

Whole Magic: The Gathering collections, estates, and accumulations of any size. In Dallas - Fort Worth we meet in public places during daylight hours; anywhere else, you can ship to us. Sellers must be 18 or older and confirm the cards are theirs to sell. We pay by cash, Zelle, business check, or PayPal. The seller FAQ covers ID, large collections, and what we do not buy.

Outside Dallas - Fort Worth? Ship it to us

If you are in the continental US and our estimate of your collection is $250 or more, we email you a prepaid, insured shipping label. Here is exactly how it works:

  1. Tell us what you have with the form above. A collection file gets the most accurate estimate; a description and a rough count work too.
  2. We reply within 24 hours with an estimated range and whether the collection qualifies for a prepaid label.
  3. We email you the label. It is prepaid and insured, and we track the box from the moment it ships. Pack the cards snugly (top loaders or sleeves for anything valuable, a sturdy box, no loose cards rattling around), print the label and drop the box off.
  4. We scan what arrives and make a firm offer within 24 to 72 hours, depending on the size of the collection. The offer is built from our scan of the cards actually in the box and itemized the same way as an in-person offer: the valuable singles card by card, the bulk at a stated rate. If the box differs from what you described, the offer simply reflects what arrived, and you see the scan.
  5. Accept and we pay by Zelle, PayPal, or business check. Every card is in the offer; cards worth $200 or more are inspected in hand before we settle, and nothing is paid until your cards have arrived. Decline and we send your cards back at your expense: we email you a quote for the return shipping, and your cards go out as soon as it is paid.

Under $250, or from Alaska, Hawaii, a US territory or outside the US, you are welcome to ship at your own expense, tracked and insured (any customs duties are yours). The same scan, 24-to-72-hour offer window and return terms apply.

Not ready to sell yet?

Get the weekly price movers, so you know when the cards in your boxes are worth more.

Weekly price movers + new guides. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

While you wait: know what you have

Our set pages show what each set is worth at current market prices, updated daily. It is the fastest way to get a realistic sense of what is sitting in your boxes, and what to expect an offer to look like relative to those numbers.