Second Main Phase Trading Co. - Magic: The Gathering singles, decks, collections bought

Starter 1999

released 1999-07-01 ยท current set value $382
Art from Grim TutorArt from PiracyArt from Devastation
Art from Grim Tutor, Piracy, Devastation
By Steven & Trevor, Second Main Phase

Starter 1999 (1999) at today's market prices. If this set is sitting in a box in your closet, this page is the honest starting point for what it is worth, refreshed every day from live market data.

What this set is worth now updated daily

$382 - the market price of one nonfoil copy of every priced printing in Starter 1999 (173 printings), as of 2026-11-21. Foils add roughly $0.00 more.

30-day change: +0.56%.

Most valuable cards

  1. Grim Tutor#1Grim Tutor$92.99
  2. Piracy#2Piracy$57.45
  3. Devastation#3Devastation$19.97
  4. Armageddon#4Armageddon$17.41
  5. Time Warp#5Time Warp$15.49
  6. Thunder Dragon#6Thunder Dragon$13.61
  7. Righteous Fury#7Righteous Fury$10.92
  8. Nature's Cloak#8Nature's Cloak$7.66
  9. Goblin Settler#9Goblin Settler$7.43
  10. Dakmor Sorceress#10Dakmor Sorceress$6.84
A number is not an offer. These are market listing prices, not what any buyer pays. Most cards by count in a real collection are bulk, sell-through is never 100%, and every card carries selling costs. What a real offer looks like, estimate your whole collection, or sell us your collection.

This week in Starter 1999from the daily prices, as of 2026-11-21

Measured card for card on printings priced both days, Starter 1999 held steady over the last week (+0.5 percent).

The most valuable card is Grim Tutor at $92.99, followed by Piracy at $57.45. The top card is 24 percent of the set's value, so a few cards matter far more than the rest.

Up this week

  • Devastation$19.97, +5%
  • Armageddon$17.41, +4%

Commander players reach for Counterspell (EDHREC #16), Nature's Lore (EDHREC #26), and Wood Elves (EDHREC #680) most from this set; every set's Commander picks.

If you are selling: the typical Starter 1999 printing lists at $0.39, so most of a stack from this set is bulk by count. What moves an offer is whether you hold any of the 7 cards listed at $10 or more in the table above. Estimate your collection.

Watch this set move one email a week

Weekly price movers + new guides. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.