


Shadows over Innistrad (2016) at today's market prices. If this set is sitting in a box in your closet, this page is the honest starting point for what it is worth, refreshed every day from live market data.
$125 - the market price of one nonfoil copy of every priced printing in Shadows over Innistrad (300 printings), as of 2026-11-21. Foils add roughly $346 more.
30-day change: +3.22%.
#1Relentless Dead$15.59
#2Cryptolith Rite$12.08
#3Eerie Interlude$5.88
#4Diregraf Colossus$5.26
#5Sorin, Grim Nemesis$4.69
#6Jace, Unraveler of Secrets$4.27
#7Second Harvest$3.72
#8Archangel Avacyn // Avacyn, the Purifier$3.10
#9Westvale Abbey // Ormendahl, Profane Prince$3.06
#10Anguished Unmaking$2.82Measured card for card on printings priced both days, Shadows over Innistrad held steady over the last week (+0.4 percent), and is up 3.2 percent across thirty days.
The most valuable card is Relentless Dead at $15.59, followed by Cryptolith Rite at $12.08. The top card is 13 percent of the set's value, so a few cards matter far more than the rest.
Commander players reach for Anguished Unmaking (EDHREC #150), Choked Estuary (EDHREC #293), and Foreboding Ruins (EDHREC #317) most from this set; every set's Commander picks.
If you are selling: the typical Shadows over Innistrad printing lists at $0.15, so most of a stack from this set is bulk by count. What moves an offer is whether you hold any of the 2 cards listed at $10 or more in the table above. Estimate your collection.